HSA Golden
  • Who We Are
  • Services
    • Landfill & Solid Waste Engineering
    • Waste Transfer & Recycling
    • Waste to Energy
    • Mining
    • Contamination & Remediation
    • Phase I and II Environmental Site Assessments
    • Site Development Engineering
    • Water Supply & Hydrogeology
    • Litigation Support
  • In the News
  • Contact Us
    • +1 407 649 5475
Couple Wins $1.2M in Chinese Drywall Settlement
November 25 2013

Couple Wins $1.2M in Chinese Drywall Settlement

  • Leadership
  • Our Clients
  • Community
  • Testimonials
  • Careers

Search

Date

John Pacenti | Daily Business Review.Com | November 12, 2013 A Miami-Dade jury will be the first to consider punitive damages against the manufacturer of tainted Chinese drywall used in thousands of homes. The jury found Friday that manufacturer Knauf Plasterboard Tianjin China and its German affiliate, Knauf Gips, was open to punitive damages based on intentional misconduct or gross indifference. It awarded Miami homeowners Jeffrey and Elisa Robin $1.2 million in compensatory damages against the Knauf companies as well as the Miami-based distributor Banner Supply Co. The punitive damage phase of the trial is set for Nov. 21 and 22 for the Knauf companies. No punitive damages were found against Banner. The compensatory damage award is intended to reimburse the Robins for the money they spent gutting their Coconut Grove home down to the studs and replacing the drywall. The couple moved into the 2-year-old Coconut Grove house in 2008 but was forced to move out because of the tainted drywall’s sulfur emissions. They moved back in January. The Robins said the gases released by the drywall caused headaches and nosebleeds as well as telltale damage to copper pipes and wiring. Jeffrey Robin is an associate at Akerman in Miami. Elisa Robin is a travel consultant. The couple is one of a handful of homeowners who decided to opt out of a global settlement in multidistrict litigation in New Orleans federal court, which settled for $800 million to $1 billion. “This is the first case in the country to go to trial on punitive damages, and it is also the first case to go against all the defendants in the distribution chain and the German affiliate,” said Victor Diaz, a partner at VM Diaz & Partners in Miami Beach who represents the Robins along with associate Jorge Lorenzo. A Miami jury awarded another couple $2.4 million in a lawsuit against Banner in June 2010, but the plaintiffs did not make a case against the Knauf companies. Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Beatrice Butchko handed Knauf a defeat before the four-week trial started, finding the defendants destroyed evidence. Butchko ruled Knauf at one time had gypsum ore from the Luneng and Hebei mines in China, synthetic gypsum and other evidence from a Knauf factory, test results and communications about the results between Knauf employees and scientists at Germany’s Fraunhofer Institute. The defendants “deliberately destroyed this physical evidence and some related testing or test results,” Butchko said. The ruling hurt Knauf’s attempt to shift blame to China’s Shandong Luneng Tai Mountain Mine Development Group Co. Ltd. Joy Lundeen, a shareholder at Stearns Weaver Miller Weissler Alhadeff & Sitterson, represented Knauf in the first phase of the trial. She did not return a call for comment by deadline. Diaz said when the case is over thousands of pages of evidence against Knauf will be available so the “true story of Chinese drywall can be told.” “The plaintiff’s case showed Knauf Gips knew in November 2006 the true nature of the defect, and they engaged in a coordinated cover-up of the problem,” Diaz said. Read more:http://www.dailybusinessreview.com/PubArticleDBR.jsp?id=1202627513307&Couple_Wins_12M_In_Chinese_Drywall_Settlement#ixzz2lgmEORpK

Project Showcase

Since 1989, HSA Golden has provided environmental engineering and consulting services to clients all over the world. Our practice areas include solid and hazardous waste management, waste-to-energy, site development engineering, environmental due diligence, and litigation support, among others. From governmental agencies and multinational, publicly traded corporations to smaller, single-office real estate and legal firms, we are proud of not only the relationships we have built, but also of the trust that our clients place in us.

Expert Testimony: Personal Injury Acid Burn Case

Site Remediation: Consolidated-Tomoka Land Co Pumphouse Site

Site Remediation: Crane Rental Corporation

Site Remediation: Men’s Wearhouse

Brownfield Remediation: Former Union 76 Station

Site Remediation: Orlando Int’l Airport West Ramp

Site Remediation: Former Kissimmee Livestock Market

Site Remediation: Former United Solvents of America

Orlando International Airport

Former McCoy Navy Base

SteelHouse Brownfield Site

Brownfield Redevelopment: The Landings

Phase I & II Environmental Site Assessment: Former Agere Semiconductor Facility

Expert Review and Evaluation: South Shore Falls Development

Expert Review and Testimony: Confidential Site

Expert Review and Testimony: Warehouse Facility

Contamination Assessment: Former Ellman Battery Site

Contamination Assessment: Altamonte Hauling Facility

Fedepalma Palm Oil Mills

Soles 1 and 2

Granja Jeroa

Limestone Mine and Cement Plant Permitting

Counts Limerock Mine

Class I Waste Transfer Station/C&D Recycling Facility

Reuters Recycling Demonstration Test

EarthGuard Recycling Center

Taft Recycling Transfer Station

VitAg Fertilizer Plant Engineering

DeSoto Construction & Demolition Debris Disposal Facility

Golden Gem Road Class III Landfill LFG System

Lake Environmental Resources C&D Disposal Facility

West Orange Environmental C&D Disposal Facility

DeSoto Landfill Leachate Storage Facility

La Duquesa Municipal Landfill

Olu Tee Landfill Design Engineering

Mid-Florida Materials Class III Recycling & Disposal Facility

we are ready for your next project

Thanks again for looking over our site and considering us for help with your project. We would be pleased to assist you with your environmental engineering and consulting needs, whether they are large or small. Please take a moment and fill out as much of the form below as you can, and someone from our firm will quickly respond to your inquiry request. Or, just pick up the phone and call us at +1 407 649 5475.





    Olu Tee Landfill Design Engineering
    • Home
    • Who We Are
    • Clients
    • Contact
    • In the News
    • Testimonials

    Quick Links

    • Home
    • Who We Are
    • Clients
    • Contact
    • In the News
    • Testimonials

    Contact Information

    HSA Golden
    11 Lake Gatlin Road
    Orlando, Florida 32806
    USA

    +1 407 649 5475

    Newsletter

    Subscribe to receive the latest news and project updates from HSA Golden.


      © 2020 HSA Golden | Environmental and Engineering Consultants | Orlando, Florida USA